Peanut butter and ketchup sandwich ??

[Dave P.]

My dad used to make peanut butter and ketchup sandwiches.
He was from Canada and moved to Michigan in the early 1930s.
I looked online and found a few mentions of these but never
knew anybody else who ever ate em.
Seeing how this forum has members all over the country and
food seems to be a frequent topic of discussion, does
anybody else eat them?
Any idea what part of the country ( if any ) it was popular?
They really don't taste as bad as they sound. The ketchup
gets mixed into the peanut butter to make a spread.
Thanks
Dave

 

[Scout943]

Never heard of it but i will try it ,ill try just about anything once . :lol: :lol: Sounds better than bologna and whipped cream sandwiches .

 

[don44]

Yuck! I think I'll pass.

 

[Tom W]

I'll just eat my ham and Velveeta with grey poupon and Jewish rye

 

[toysoldier]

Doesn't sound good to me, but my favorite is toasted whole wheat, peanut butter, mayo, and a thick slice of Vidalia onion.

 

[skeeter]

Tomato is a fruit, so I guess its a variation of a PB and J.

 

[Fox Mike]

Gonna have to give it a try. I have carried peanut butter and baked bean sandwiches when hunting. They DO fill the 'hole'!

 

[Poco Oso]

Doesn't sound good to me, but my favorite is toasted whole wheat, peanut butter, mayo, and a thick slice of Vidalia onion.

Never tried a peanut butter and ketchup sandwich, but peanut butter and mayo (hold the onion) is one of my favorites . My wife looks at me like I got it out of the back yard though. She doesn't know what she's missing. :wink: I guess I'll have to try these now.

 

[32shooter]

I have never tried a PB and ketchup but do eat peanut butter and tomato sandwiches, so can't imagine it would be to bad.

 

[Snake45]

Yuck! I think I'll pass.

I'm with you, Don. :wink:

 

[markallen]

My Dad always ate peanut butter, and tomatoes on toast.
For years I just couldn't eat it, but I tried it once and now I'm hooked. It's the only way I'll eat peanut butter now.

 

[RUFFBIRD]

Ketchup on eggs & Molasses with peanut-butter is fantastic....
One never knows until ya try it!

 

[Mike J]

Doesn't sound good to me, but my favorite is toasted whole wheat, peanut butter, mayo, and a thick slice of Vidalia onion.

Never tried a peanut butter and ketchup sandwich, but peanut butter and mayo (hold the onion) is one of my favorites . My wife looks at me like I got it out of the back yard though. She doesn't know what she's missing. :wink: I guess I'll have to try these now.

I have never a had peanut butter & ketchup sandwich. I grew up eating not just peanut butter & mayo but peanut butter, mayonnaise & banana sandwiches. They rock.

 

[cas6969]

I've run into two people who like tunafish & peanut butter. (used it like most people would mix in mayonnaise)

 

[rugerguy211]

Never heard of PB and ketchup. I'm not a very adventurous eater so will probably pass on trying it. Although, I do have a daughter in law who uses ketchup on her salad rather than any traditional salad dressing, so maybe I'll suggest it to her.
I'm a PB and jelly, PB and fluff (a Fluffernutter for those not from the New England Area), and straight PB (my favorite) type of guy.

 

[Poco Oso]

Doesn't sound good to me, but my favorite is toasted whole wheat, peanut butter, mayo, and a thick slice of Vidalia onion.

Never tried a peanut butter and ketchup sandwich, but peanut butter and mayo (hold the onion) is one of my favorites . My wife looks at me like I got it out of the back yard though. She doesn't know what she's missing. :wink: I guess I'll have to try these now.

I have never a had peanut butter & ketchup sandwich. I grew up eating not just peanut butter & mayo but peanut butter, mayonnaise & banana sandwiches. They rock.

Fry 'em, like grilled cheese. :wink:

 

[gramps]

I like PB on rye with either dill pickles or banana. I like my vidalias on buttered rye with ketsup and mustard. I understand everyone is unique, some more so than others. :mrgreen:
gramps

 

[RSIno1]

PB & Banana not ketchup that's for eggs and hashbrowns from McDonalds to kill the taste.

 

[#1rugerman]

Had a friend who ate pineapple sandwiches with mayo on one slice of bread and mustard on the other. I would make the same sandwich but skipped the mustard.

 

[Mega Twin]

Anything with peanut butter has got to be good.
Peanut butter and bologna sandwiches are good,too.