Well, I like the Carry a lot or I wouldn't have recommended it. The plain R1 and the orphan stepchild, the Enhanced, are also nice.
I'm sure you may get some negative comments, i.e., the cast frame, but supposedly
the Carry frames are machined (which may mean and I'm not sure a step above castings). Some people just can't stand the idea of a cast frame which is what Ruger also has. (Remington specifically says machined, not forged.) I really don't think you'll find many criticisms of the Remy on the Internet and you know how that goes regarding opinions, informed or otherwise.
The only way you're going to know if you really like the Rem is to hold one, try the action, and compare it to
other makers. I think they sell very well but get lost in all the hoopla, recommendations that always come for Springers, Kimbers and Colts and then the higher end stuff like Les Baers.
By comparison Colts, and I own Colts including a Series 70 recent manufacture, may seem a bit crude, particularly the sharp edges at the magazine well, around the ejection port, the front of the frame.
I don't want to start a guide rod war here but Ruger and Remy do not, at least not yet, offer any full length guide rod models and I like that too.